Critics question the transparency and true float of EIGEN tokens

Today, enjoy the 0xResearch newsletter on Blockworks.co. Tomorrow, get the news delivered directly to your inbox. Subscribe to the 0xResearch newsletter. 

The FUD around EigenLayer tokenomics

Here’s how private investor allocations into pre-launch tokens generally work:

1. You are a reputable name or a KOL with many Twitter followers, and projects want your clout.
2. A project offers you a percentage of locked tokens at a favorable price, so you agree to invest.
3. On the day the project launches its “token generation event” (TGE) and tokens become tradable, your locked allocation of tokens enter a “cliff” period.
4. That cliff is typically about a year (though in bull markets has been known to drop to six or even three months), during which your tokens are effectively locked up.
5. Once that cliff is up, your tokens enter a “vesting” period — typically two to four years — during which your locked tokens begin to slowly unlock and become liquid and tradable.

Things are set up this way to create long-term incentive alignment between investors and projects to build a successful product, and ultimately deter predatory dumping on retail investors.

EigenLayer finally made its native EIGEN token transferable yesterday, amid a barrage of criticism around the opaqueness of EIGEN’s true float (circulating supply). 

That is pretty important to know because low-float tokens are more volatile and subject to less market price discovery, and are therefore predatory for the unsuspecting retail investor eyeing them hungrily on the Binance mobile app.

After accounting for unclaimed EIGEN and the 73 million EIGEN already restaked on EigenLayer, Kairos Research estimated that the real float of EIGEN was about 2.42% — a float even shockingly lower than Worldcoin’s (WLD) ~4.9% — though EigenLayer disputed that number.

And it gets more complicated.

The “locked” EIGEN tokens by EigenLayer investors are apparently not entirely locked.

During the so-called locked cliff period, EigenLayer investors can already stake their “locked” tokens, receive rewards, and begin selling those rewards on the open market. As noted in their just-updated docs:

“*EIGEN staking: Eigen Labs Investors are not restricted from staking EIGEN on EigenLayer. As such, investors may choose to stake their EIGEN and receive staking rewards the same as any other user. EIGEN provided by Eigen Labs to investors is subject to the Lockup Schedule, but EIGEN investors receive from staking will not be subject to the Lockup Schedule.”

But if locked tokens are accruing a yield, then that is arguably not a “locked” token.

I was under the impression that this was a rare and frowned upon practice that Celestia started, but it’s apparently becoming a standard playbook with several L1 projects including Sui, Sei and Aptos.

Yield-generating “locked” tokens defeats the whole purpose of locking up private investor tokens for “incentive alignment,” and it’s also effectively a form of double-dipping. Worse still, it double-dips from a reward pool that could have been allocated to actual productive capital, e.g. restaking and securing an EigenLayer AVS.

In EigenLayer’s defense, there is at least a cap on those emitted rewards. Based on its docs, 1% of the total EIGEN supply ($60 million) is emitted as rewards annually, and 25% of that is reserved for EIGEN stakers, while the other 75% goes to ETH stakers on EigenLayer.

I guess when EigenLayer was talking about “restaking,” it had in mind its investors too.

— Donovan Choy

Chart of the Day

USDS heads skyward:

Source: Sky.money

Sky’s USDS stablecoin has hit $1.1 billion since its inception exactly one month ago. In Maker’s rebrand to Sky, existing DAI holders have the option to convert DAI to the rebranded USDS.

The joint market cap of both USDS and DAI is now nearly $5.9 billion, the highest it’s been on a year-to-date basis.

— Donovan Choy 

Degen Corner Simple bitcoin staking

We previously looked at BOB Stake for the Bitcoin/Ethereum “hybrid L2” BOB, and Stroom, a liquid staking provider for the Lightning Network.

To further the theme of safe bitcoin staking for noobs, leading staking-as-a-service provider P2P.org today introduced a Babylon staking API to offer exchanges, custodians and wallet providers a way to integrate bitcoin staking directly into their platforms.

Instead of switching to a third-party interface, individual users and institutional investors can use the service to access bitcoin staking rewards through a familiar platform. Candidates include exchanges, wallets and LRT providers.

The API is designed to simplify the complex tasks of creating, signing and broadcasting bitcoin transactions, for instance by handling the RPC connection.

In terms of future updates, P2P plans to add features like batch staking — allowing users to generate multiple staking transactions from a single address. This will help institutions stake bitcoin efficiently before the Babylon BTC cap is reached.

— Macauley Peterson

Start your day with top crypto insights from David Canellis and Katherine Ross. Subscribe to the Empire newsletter.

Explore the growing intersection between crypto, macroeconomics, policy and finance with Ben Strack, Casey Wagner and Felix Jauvin. Subscribe to the Forward Guidance newsletter.

Get alpha directly in your inbox with the 0xResearch newsletter — market highlights, charts, degen trade ideas, governance updates, and more.

The Lightspeed newsletter is all things Solana, in your inbox, every day. Subscribe to daily Solana news from Jack Kubinec and Jeff Albus.